|
29 Oct 2013
Status : this preprint was under review for the journal AMT but the revision was not accepted.
Estimation of waste water treatment plant methane emissions: methodology and results from a short campaign
C. E. Yver-Kwok , D. Müller , C. Caldow , B. Lebegue , J. G. Mønster , C. W. Rella , C. Scheutz , M. Schmidt , M. Ramonet , T. Warneke , G. Broquet , and P. Ciais
This paper describes different methods to estimate methane emissions at different scales. These methods are applied to a waste water treatment plant (WWTP) located in Valence, France. We show that Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) measurements as well as Cavity Ring Down Spectroscopy (CRDS) can be used to measure emissions from the process to the regional scale. To estimate the total emissions, we investigate a tracer release method (using C2 H2 ) and the Radon tracer method (using 222 Rn). For process-scale emissions, both tracer release and chamber techniques were used. We show that the tracer release method is suitable to quantify facility- and some process-scale emissions, while the Radon tracer method encompasses not only the treatment station but also a large area around. Thus the Radon tracer method is more representative of the regional emissions around the city. Uncertainties for each method are described. Applying the methods to CH4 emissions, we find that the main source of emissions of the plant was not identified with certainty during this short campaign, although the primary source of emissions is likely to be from solid sludge. Overall, the waste water treatment plant represents a small part (3%) of the methane emissions of the city of Valence and its surroundings,which is in agreement with the national inventories.
Received: 02 Aug 2013 – Discussion started: 29 Oct 2013
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
C. E. Yver-Kwok , D. Müller , C. Caldow , B. Lebegue , J. G. Mønster , C. W. Rella , C. Scheutz , M. Schmidt , M. Ramonet , T. Warneke , G. Broquet , and P. Ciais
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
C. E. Yver-Kwok , D. Müller , C. Caldow , B. Lebegue , J. G. Mønster , C. W. Rella , C. Scheutz , M. Schmidt , M. Ramonet , T. Warneke , G. Broquet , and P. Ciais
C. E. Yver-Kwok , D. Müller , C. Caldow , B. Lebegue , J. G. Mønster , C. W. Rella , C. Scheutz , M. Schmidt , M. Ramonet , T. Warneke , G. Broquet , and P. Ciais
Viewed
Total article views: 2,237 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,313
813
111
2,237
108
118
HTML: 1,313
PDF: 813
XML: 111
Total: 2,237
BibTeX: 108
EndNote: 118
Views and downloads (calculated since 29 Oct 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Oct 2013
34
12
0
46
Nov 2013
47
53
3
103
Dec 2013
27
30
2
59
Jan 2014
10
19
4
33
Feb 2014
24
27
3
54
Mar 2014
20
27
0
47
Apr 2014
10
19
0
29
May 2014
5
12
0
17
Jun 2014
9
7
1
17
Jul 2014
6
18
0
24
Aug 2014
7
11
0
18
Sep 2014
11
13
0
24
Oct 2014
6
9
2
17
Nov 2014
3
12
0
15
Dec 2014
3
13
1
17
Jan 2015
7
10
0
17
Feb 2015
10
4
0
14
Mar 2015
9
5
1
15
Apr 2015
14
4
0
18
May 2015
3
3
1
7
Jun 2015
11
0
11
Jul 2015
12
5
0
17
Aug 2015
7
10
1
18
Sep 2015
2
0
2
Oct 2015
7
4
0
11
Nov 2015
7
3
0
10
Dec 2015
1
1
0
2
Jan 2016
12
9
0
21
Feb 2016
5
11
0
16
Mar 2016
10
4
1
15
Apr 2016
4
6
0
10
May 2016
10
9
3
22
Jun 2016
8
4
3
15
Jul 2016
9
2
2
13
Aug 2016
10
2
1
13
Sep 2016
5
1
0
6
Oct 2016
8
1
0
9
Nov 2016
5
1
0
6
Dec 2016
4
2
0
6
Jan 2017
10
1
2
13
Feb 2017
10
6
0
16
Mar 2017
23
4
4
31
Apr 2017
28
12
6
46
May 2017
21
6
1
28
Jun 2017
15
10
2
27
Jul 2017
6
7
0
13
Aug 2017
4
7
1
12
Sep 2017
1
7
0
8
Oct 2017
5
7
0
12
Nov 2017
5
5
0
10
Dec 2017
3
7
0
10
Jan 2018
9
7
0
16
Feb 2018
12
4
3
19
Mar 2018
5
8
0
13
Apr 2018
10
5
1
16
May 2018
8
9
0
17
Jun 2018
3
11
0
14
Jul 2018
5
6
0
11
Aug 2018
6
10
0
16
Sep 2018
7
9
0
16
Oct 2018
5
9
0
14
Nov 2018
6
15
0
21
Dec 2018
5
8
0
13
Jan 2019
5
11
0
16
Feb 2019
4
10
0
14
Mar 2019
6
15
0
21
Apr 2019
6
9
0
15
May 2019
3
17
0
20
Jun 2019
4
4
0
8
Jul 2019
10
6
0
16
Aug 2019
9
11
0
20
Sep 2019
7
8
0
15
Oct 2019
6
11
0
17
Nov 2019
1
3
0
4
Dec 2019
6
4
0
10
Jan 2020
11
3
0
14
Feb 2020
9
2
0
11
Mar 2020
3
4
0
7
Apr 2020
4
2
1
7
May 2020
4
2
0
6
Jun 2020
2
0
2
Jul 2020
9
8
9
26
Aug 2020
6
2
4
12
Sep 2020
4
0
4
Oct 2020
9
1
1
11
Nov 2020
8
1
0
9
Dec 2020
7
5
1
13
Jan 2021
12
0
12
Feb 2021
6
5
0
11
Mar 2021
6
1
0
7
Apr 2021
8
3
0
11
May 2021
6
2
0
8
Jun 2021
12
3
0
15
Jul 2021
7
1
0
8
Aug 2021
13
3
0
16
Sep 2021
4
2
0
6
Oct 2021
6
5
0
11
Nov 2021
13
2
1
16
Dec 2021
9
2
0
11
Jan 2022
16
1
0
17
Feb 2022
22
3
0
25
Mar 2022
5
1
6
Apr 2022
8
4
1
13
May 2022
8
2
1
11
Jun 2022
7
0
7
Jul 2022
9
1
0
10
Aug 2022
8
1
0
9
Sep 2022
12
1
1
14
Oct 2022
17
1
1
19
Nov 2022
13
0
13
Dec 2022
19
0
19
Jan 2023
17
4
1
22
Feb 2023
11
4
1
16
Mar 2023
14
1
0
15
Apr 2023
6
2
3
11
May 2023
13
4
1
18
Jun 2023
10
2
2
14
Jul 2023
16
3
3
22
Aug 2023
10
4
3
17
Sep 2023
14
4
6
24
Oct 2023
10
3
1
14
Nov 2023
13
4
0
17
Dec 2023
10
5
1
16
Jan 2024
13
0
13
Feb 2024
20
3
1
24
Mar 2024
19
6
3
28
Apr 2024
16
4
5
25
May 2024
16
1
0
17
Jun 2024
20
4
3
27
Jul 2024
12
5
3
20
Aug 2024
19
1
0
20
Sep 2024
9
0
9
Oct 2024
10
2
2
14
Nov 2024
14
1
15
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 29 Oct 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Oct 2013
34
12
0
Nov 2013
81
65
3
Dec 2013
108
95
5
Jan 2014
118
114
9
Feb 2014
142
141
12
Mar 2014
162
168
12
Apr 2014
172
187
12
May 2014
177
199
12
Jun 2014
186
206
13
Jul 2014
192
224
13
Aug 2014
199
235
13
Sep 2014
210
248
13
Oct 2014
216
257
15
Nov 2014
219
269
15
Dec 2014
222
282
16
Jan 2015
229
292
16
Feb 2015
239
296
16
Mar 2015
248
301
17
Apr 2015
262
305
17
May 2015
265
308
18
Jun 2015
276
308
18
Jul 2015
288
313
18
Aug 2015
295
323
19
Sep 2015
295
325
19
Oct 2015
302
329
19
Nov 2015
309
332
19
Dec 2015
310
333
19
Jan 2016
322
342
19
Feb 2016
327
353
19
Mar 2016
337
357
20
Apr 2016
341
363
20
May 2016
351
372
23
Jun 2016
359
376
26
Jul 2016
368
378
28
Aug 2016
378
380
29
Sep 2016
383
381
29
Oct 2016
391
382
29
Nov 2016
396
383
29
Dec 2016
400
385
29
Jan 2017
410
386
31
Feb 2017
420
392
31
Mar 2017
443
396
35
Apr 2017
471
408
41
May 2017
492
414
42
Jun 2017
507
424
44
Jul 2017
513
431
44
Aug 2017
517
438
45
Sep 2017
518
445
45
Oct 2017
523
452
45
Nov 2017
528
457
45
Dec 2017
531
464
45
Jan 2018
540
471
45
Feb 2018
552
475
48
Mar 2018
557
483
48
Apr 2018
567
488
49
May 2018
575
497
49
Jun 2018
578
508
49
Jul 2018
583
514
49
Aug 2018
589
524
49
Sep 2018
596
533
49
Oct 2018
601
542
49
Nov 2018
607
557
49
Dec 2018
612
565
49
Jan 2019
617
576
49
Feb 2019
621
586
49
Mar 2019
627
601
49
Apr 2019
633
610
49
May 2019
636
627
49
Jun 2019
640
631
49
Jul 2019
650
637
49
Aug 2019
659
648
49
Sep 2019
666
656
49
Oct 2019
672
667
49
Nov 2019
673
670
49
Dec 2019
679
674
49
Jan 2020
690
677
49
Feb 2020
699
679
49
Mar 2020
702
683
49
Apr 2020
706
685
50
May 2020
710
687
50
Jun 2020
712
687
50
Jul 2020
721
695
59
Aug 2020
727
697
63
Sep 2020
731
697
63
Oct 2020
740
698
64
Nov 2020
748
699
64
Dec 2020
755
704
65
Jan 2021
767
704
65
Feb 2021
773
709
65
Mar 2021
779
710
65
Apr 2021
787
713
65
May 2021
793
715
65
Jun 2021
805
718
65
Jul 2021
812
719
65
Aug 2021
825
722
65
Sep 2021
829
724
65
Oct 2021
835
729
65
Nov 2021
848
731
66
Dec 2021
857
733
66
Jan 2022
873
734
66
Feb 2022
895
737
66
Mar 2022
900
737
67
Apr 2022
908
741
68
May 2022
916
743
69
Jun 2022
923
743
69
Jul 2022
932
744
69
Aug 2022
940
745
69
Sep 2022
952
746
70
Oct 2022
969
747
71
Nov 2022
982
747
71
Dec 2022
1,001
747
71
Jan 2023
1,018
751
72
Feb 2023
1,029
755
73
Mar 2023
1,043
756
73
Apr 2023
1,049
758
76
May 2023
1,062
762
77
Jun 2023
1,072
764
79
Jul 2023
1,088
767
82
Aug 2023
1,098
771
85
Sep 2023
1,112
775
91
Oct 2023
1,122
778
92
Nov 2023
1,135
782
92
Dec 2023
1,145
787
93
Jan 2024
1,158
787
93
Feb 2024
1,178
790
94
Mar 2024
1,197
796
97
Apr 2024
1,213
800
102
May 2024
1,229
801
102
Jun 2024
1,249
805
105
Jul 2024
1,261
810
108
Aug 2024
1,280
811
108
Sep 2024
1,289
811
108
Oct 2024
1,299
813
110
Nov 2024
1,313
813
111
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 21 Nov 2024