the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
The UNAM-MARine Aerosol Tank (UNAM-MARAT): An Evaluation of the Ice-Nucleating Abilities of seawater from the Gulf of Mexico and the Mexican Pacific
Abstract. Although several studies have shown that sea spray aerosol (SSA) has the potential to act as ice nucleating particles (INP) impacting cloud formation, there is a lack of marine INP studies in tropical latitudes. This is partly due to the unavailability of local oceanographic cruises that perform aerosol-cloud interaction studies in the tropics, as well as the scarcity of appropriate aerosol and cloud microphysics instrumentation. The present study shows the development of the UNAM-MARine Aerosol Tank (UNAM-MARAT), a device that simulates wave breaking to generate SSA particles with the main purpose to characterize their physicochemical properties including their ice nucleating abilities. The UNAM-MARAT was characterized using Instant Ocean Sea Salt and its potential to study ambient sea waters was evaluated with sea seawater samples collected from the Port of Veracruz (PoV) in the Gulf of Mexico, and from the Bay of Acapulco (BoA) and the Bay of Santiago- Manzanillo (BoSM) in the Mexican Pacific Ocean. The portable and automatic UNAM-MARAT is able to generate aerosol particle concentrations as high as 2000 cm-3 covering a wide range of sizes, from 30 nm to 10 μm, similar to those found in the ambient marine boundary layer. The SSA generated from the three natural seawater samples was found to act as INP via immersion freezing, with INP concentrations as high as 130.7 L-1. The particles generated from the BoA seawater samples were the most efficient INPs, reporting the highest ice active site density (ns) values between -20 and -30 °C. Our results also show the direct relationship between particle size and its composition. Larger particles (> 1 μm) were found to be enriched in sodium chloride. In contrast, the fraction of Ca2+, Mg2+, and NO3- was found to increase with decreasing the particle size from 10 μm to 320 nm. This suggests the presence of dissolved organic material in the submicron particles.
- Preprint
(1946 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(447 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (extended)
-
RC1: 'Comment on amt-2024-172', Anonymous Referee #1, 03 Dec 2024
reply
General comments:
This paper is written on the development, characterization, and application of a marine aerosol generator. The authors provide a very thorough review of relevant literature both in the introduction and throughout the manuscript. Multiple tests were conducted to validate the results of their system, while also comparing to results of similar systems. The system is then applied to several samples to compare their size distributions, chemistry, and INP concentrations. The results are thorough and make for a linear story as well.
Specific comments:
- Lines 164-166: Cite or mention Stokes et al. as reference for system
- Line 178: Provide brief explanation on why the chosen cascade was the most suitable.
- Are OPC counts biased towards the lowest bins?
- 3.1: Which cascade was used for the background particle test?
- 3.1: At what (time) point does the SSA reach a steady state? This information would be useful.
- 3.2: Which cascade is the best/most realistic? Should be explicitly stated here.
- It should be mentioned how the longer delay also allows for resettling/reformation of the SML, which is important for the chemistry of the particles.
- Line 179 states that with 40 L of water, the waterfall is roughly 10 cm, however Lines 401-402 state that a 40 L fill results in a 22.5 cm waterfall height. This is a 2x difference. Please address this discrepancy.
- Line 464-465: Not necessary to state here that coarse mode particles can be produced. This point is made and should be stated in section 3.5
- The authors reference how similar works induced phytoplankton blooms and that is what accounts for varying INP concentrations in other works. A comparison of INP concentrations from their work to INP concentrations from the start of the blooms (prior to culture additions) for other works would be a more appropriate comparison and useful addition.
- Centrifugal pumps can be harsh on biology and this could be affecting overall INP concentrations. Have authors considered this and measured if the number of INP at specific temperature changes over time? Another option is to perform experiments with other pumps to test affect on INP concentration.
Technical comments:
- Line 74: Delete “in.”
- Line 120: Suggest using “species” instead of “particles” as most particles can contain more than just a diatom or dinoflagellate.
- Line 190: Water flow or air flow?
- Figure 1: This is meticulous, but only 8 screws are accounted for in diagram and text states that 10 are used to hold lid.
- Line 275: Section 2.4 label
- Line 334: *produced
- Line 481: Should be decreases, not increases
- Line 613: *tank
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/amt-2024-172-RC1
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
137 | 36 | 6 | 179 | 29 | 3 | 4 |
- HTML: 137
- PDF: 36
- XML: 6
- Total: 179
- Supplement: 29
- BibTeX: 3
- EndNote: 4
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1