Please find my comments attached.

This is a very well written manuscript with an obvious novel contribution to cloud remote sensing studies that make it worthy of publication in AMT. However, numerous specific and technical edits need to be made prior to publication, and the Introduction section (and other sections as appropriate) need to include and reference other relevant (not to mention recent) studies and works on, for example, Ka-W or radiometric + high frequency radar retrieval work. The authors also need to clarify if their analysis is based on a single case study, or all good EPCAPE related data from the campaign. The approach and work are otherwise outstanding, and my suggested edits should not take much time to address. See attached document for my complete review.