Articles | Volume 18, issue 17
https://doi.org/10.5194/amt-18-4515-2025
© Author(s) 2025. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Potential CO2 measurement capabilities of a transportable Near Infrared Laser Heterodyne Radiometer (LHR)
Download
- Final revised paper (published on 12 Sep 2025)
- Preprint (discussion started on 26 Mar 2025)
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor
| : Report abuse
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2025-250', Anonymous Referee #1, 08 May 2025
- AC2: 'Reply on RC1', El Kattar Marie-Thérèse, 25 Jul 2025
-
EC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2025-250', Frank Hase, 26 May 2025
- AC3: 'Reply on EC1', El Kattar Marie-Thérèse, 25 Jul 2025
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2025-250', Anonymous Referee #2, 01 Jul 2025
- AC1: 'Reply on RC2', El Kattar Marie-Thérèse, 25 Jul 2025
Peer review completion
AR – Author's response | RR – Referee report | ED – Editor decision | EF – Editorial file upload
AR by El Kattar Marie-Thérèse on behalf of the Authors (25 Jul 2025)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
EF by Daria Karpachova (29 Jul 2025)
Author's response
EF by Daria Karpachova (29 Jul 2025)
Manuscript
ED: Publish as is (29 Jul 2025) by Frank Hase
AR by El Kattar Marie-Thérèse on behalf of the Authors (29 Jul 2025)
Manuscript
The manuscript describes the development and analysis of a laser heterodyne radiometer (LHR) using a widely tunable diode laser. This allows – unlike most recent LHR systems for trace gas remote sensing, which typically rely on quantum cascade lasers or similar – the measurements of full rotation-vibrations bands of molecules like CO2 and an easier access to multiple species. The authors combine this with the high spectral resolution typical for LHRs to retrieve vertical profiles of CO2 in solar occultation measurements. They follow this up with comprehensive analysis of the information content within the spectrum and of the error budget. I consider the content highly significant, for the current development of LHR systems for remote sensing in the atmosphere, and the manuscript well written. Further, I appreciate the thorough addressing of information content and channel selection - since it is time consuming it is often done in an ad-hoc trial and error way (unless maybe for large projects), so it is nice to see a practical example in recent literature. However, I think there are a few points were additional clarifications and minor improvements would allow the manuscript to be equally accessible for those members of the community with a stronger background in atmospheric remote sensing as well as for those with their main background in lab spectroscopy. So I would like to propose the following general remarks and comments for the authors to consider moving forwards and point out a few clarifications which seem necessary to me. Since I do not bring a specific expertise on the matter of the details of the retrieval, my comments will be mostly limited to technical corrections and questions of understanding in the corresponding sections.
General Remarks:
Many acronyms are not explained (TCCON COCCON MAGIC FORUM). With some this might be fine (i.e. citation to the network main paper), but with other not.
You write a lot about your Model and Retrieval, but in the end it is a bit vague to me what exactly you use in your state vector (for the gases: mixing ratios, concentrations, column densities) and in your measurement vector (radiances, transmittance, ...) - I would consider this the most relevant information on a higher level of how your retrieval is designed.
Regarding your results of the information content analysis of the spectrum (Figure 4 and 5), I am not completely convinced, since I miss a few points in the discussion:
Line-by-line comments:
9f: I find the first sentence a bit vague and not adding anything of value – the same could be said about many methods.
10f: Semantically wrong in my opinion. Heterodyne detection is a method, not an instrument and thus can not be “transportable” or similar.
23: I would say the “radiative impacts on the atmosphere” of higher greenhouse gas (GHG) concentrations is well sorted since a few decades and “studying the effects of climate change” with an instrument as presented sounds to me at best like the analysis of changes in biological sources and sinks of GHGs.
24ff (“In addition to [..]”): This is quite a generic reference with an even broader reference. If you cite the latest IPCC report for something like this, I would ask you to be more precise where in the thousands of pages you get that from.
31: I wouldn’t call the logistical requirements of COCCON “low”. While the EM27/SUN is portable (unlike the instruments of the TCCON network), the logistics behind operating a network of them, ensuring the comparability of the instruments, etc. is quite substantial and an achievement.
35: If you argue via cost effectiveness, could you give a rough number/price?
35: What sensitivity limits are you talking about?
55: Since lock-in amplifiers are not necessarily know to the everybody in the target group of this journal I would ask you to add half a sentence explaining why you modulate the light source with a chopper.
68: Can you also give details on the product concerning the “square law detector”? I think this could help avoiding misunderstandings, since many readers will think "photo diode" when reading this in the context of this journal and the topic.
77: I think this equation is not clear at all, even after reading the cited reference. At a minimum, the chosen definition for SNR should be reiterated and the relevant assumptions stated (relative strengths of signals, shot noise limits, etc.).
82: You state the theoretical SNR and then introduce your measurements, but I do not find how well the actual measured SNR compares to the theoretical one.
84: “an information content study”?
90: Why a Gaussian line profile? This would be rather unusual (and wrong). You should at least use Voight, but even this is not necessarily up to current standards.
94: What is the LATMOS function?
103f: To make any statement about the consistency a plot of the residuals between measurement and forward model is required.
Figure 2: please be more clear in the layout and caption of the figure what is measured data and what is simulation.
144: I “I” a unity matrix?
146f: You say that “Sm is calculated [..]” but then proceed to give an equation for Smeas..
161: I don’t get the division by 100 in the equation. Looks to me like a conversion from percent to a straight number, but perror is sometimes given as absolute value including units (i.e. for the temperature) in your table.
190: To my understanding 10° measurements are rather unrealistic for high quality direct sun observations.
200f: In a sense, this is obvious - higher up, lower pressure, less molecules in a fixed height layer. This is one of the reasons why the atmospheric retrieval codes I am familiar with use equidistant levels in pressure, which result in (roughly) equal amounts of molecules per layer. So here, it is unclear to me, how much if not all of the described effect is due to the lower number of molecules.
208: Maybe change the order of the tables? Table 4 is needed before Table 2.
Figure 3: Please add a better explanation (maybe linked to your formalism for A) what the different lines are.
235: Optical path difference? You are talking about a longer path in the atmosphere I assume?
Table 3: What definition of SNR is utilized here? Is it comparable between the different measurements/works? Also: What CHRIS is remains unclear to somebody not familiar with the corresponding paper.
Figure 5: Axis ticks very hard to read.