X. C. Liu , T. C. Gao , and L. Liu
During the sampling process of precipitation particles by optical disdrometers, the randomness of particles and sampling variability has great impact on the accuracy of precipitation variables. Based on a marked point model of raindrop size distribution, the effect of sampling variation on drop size distribution and velocity distribution measurement using optical disdrometers are analyzed by Monte Carlo simulation. The results show that the samples number, rain rate, drop size distribution, and sampling size have different influences on the accuracy of rainfall variables. The relative errors of rainfall variables caused by sampling variation in a descending order as: water concentration, mean diameter, mass weighed mean diameter, mean volume diameter, radar reflectivity factor, and number density, which are independent with samples number basically; the relative error of rain variables are positively correlated with the margin probability, which is also positively correlated with the rain rate and the mean diameter of raindrops; the sampling size is one of the main factors that influence the margin probability, with the decreasing of sampling area, especially the decreasing of short side of sample size, the probability of margin raindrops is getting greater, hence the error of rain variables are getting greater, and the variables of median size raindrops have the maximum error. To ensure the relative error of rainfall variables measured by optical disdrometer less than 1%, the width of light beam should be at least 40 mm.
Received: 12 Nov 2012 – Discussion started: 19 Dec 2012
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
X. C. Liu , T. C. Gao , and L. Liu
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
X. C. Liu , T. C. Gao , and L. Liu
X. C. Liu , T. C. Gao , and L. Liu
Viewed
Total article views: 2,455 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,711
569
175
2,455
205
219
HTML: 1,711
PDF: 569
XML: 175
Total: 2,455
BibTeX: 205
EndNote: 219
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
6
14
6
26
Mar 2013
5
14
5
24
Apr 2013
4
7
0
11
May 2013
28
10
0
38
Jun 2013
6
10
1
17
Jul 2013
4
7
0
11
Aug 2013
4
9
0
13
Sep 2013
6
0
6
Oct 2013
4
10
0
14
Nov 2013
3
8
1
12
Dec 2013
3
5
2
10
Jan 2014
5
19
2
26
Feb 2014
6
12
3
21
Mar 2014
10
7
2
19
Apr 2014
8
12
2
22
May 2014
3
10
0
13
Jun 2014
3
12
0
15
Jul 2014
4
10
0
14
Aug 2014
2
9
0
11
Sep 2014
2
8
1
11
Oct 2014
8
1
9
Nov 2014
3
9
0
12
Dec 2014
9
0
9
Jan 2015
10
9
0
19
Feb 2015
8
0
8
Mar 2015
7
4
1
12
Apr 2015
12
2
0
14
May 2015
3
2
0
5
Jun 2015
5
0
5
Jul 2015
7
1
0
8
Aug 2015
4
4
0
8
Sep 2015
3
3
0
6
Oct 2015
6
3
0
9
Nov 2015
5
3
0
8
Dec 2015
1
0
1
Jan 2016
8
1
0
9
Feb 2016
9
3
0
12
Mar 2016
10
1
1
12
Apr 2016
8
1
0
9
May 2016
10
3
5
18
Jun 2016
9
5
4
18
Jul 2016
8
3
3
14
Aug 2016
8
6
1
15
Sep 2016
5
0
5
Oct 2016
12
1
4
17
Nov 2016
2
1
0
3
Dec 2016
6
1
1
8
Jan 2017
9
4
1
14
Feb 2017
7
1
3
11
Mar 2017
22
4
3
29
Apr 2017
27
6
4
37
May 2017
21
2
2
25
Jun 2017
15
4
2
21
Jul 2017
3
0
3
Aug 2017
7
7
2
16
Sep 2017
2
1
0
3
Oct 2017
3
1
0
4
Nov 2017
3
1
0
4
Dec 2017
6
5
0
11
Jan 2018
7
3
0
10
Feb 2018
14
1
3
18
Mar 2018
3
2
0
5
Apr 2018
10
3
1
14
May 2018
5
4
1
10
Jun 2018
2
1
0
3
Jul 2018
6
2
0
8
Aug 2018
9
5
0
14
Sep 2018
7
5
0
12
Oct 2018
4
2
0
6
Nov 2018
9
5
0
14
Dec 2018
6
1
0
7
Jan 2019
5
3
0
8
Feb 2019
4
1
0
5
Mar 2019
2
0
2
Apr 2019
5
7
1
13
May 2019
2
3
0
5
Jun 2019
4
1
0
5
Jul 2019
5
3
1
9
Aug 2019
5
2
0
7
Sep 2019
4
2
0
6
Oct 2019
0
Nov 2019
6
0
6
Dec 2019
0
Jan 2020
7
4
0
11
Feb 2020
4
1
0
5
Mar 2020
1
2
0
3
Apr 2020
3
4
1
8
May 2020
3
1
0
4
Jun 2020
6
0
6
Jul 2020
10
5
5
20
Aug 2020
6
3
4
13
Sep 2020
4
1
0
5
Oct 2020
6
3
1
10
Nov 2020
5
1
1
7
Dec 2020
4
4
1
9
Jan 2021
5
2
0
7
Feb 2021
7
5
0
12
Mar 2021
5
4
0
9
Apr 2021
5
3
0
8
May 2021
5
3
0
8
Jun 2021
7
3
0
10
Jul 2021
7
2
0
9
Aug 2021
6
6
1
13
Sep 2021
3
1
0
4
Oct 2021
8
2
0
10
Nov 2021
12
3
0
15
Dec 2021
7
3
0
10
Jan 2022
4
2
0
6
Feb 2022
6
0
6
Mar 2022
6
3
2
11
Apr 2022
6
6
2
14
May 2022
4
0
4
Jun 2022
3
0
3
Jul 2022
4
1
0
5
Aug 2022
7
3
0
10
Sep 2022
11
2
0
13
Oct 2022
6
1
1
8
Nov 2022
12
2
1
15
Dec 2022
5
1
1
7
Jan 2023
5
1
0
6
Feb 2023
8
3
0
11
Mar 2023
10
1
0
11
Apr 2023
6
1
0
7
May 2023
6
4
1
11
Jun 2023
6
2
2
10
Jul 2023
11
2
3
16
Aug 2023
12
3
1
16
Sep 2023
15
3
4
22
Oct 2023
9
1
0
10
Nov 2023
8
1
9
Dec 2023
4
0
4
Jan 2024
7
0
7
Feb 2024
11
0
11
Mar 2024
34
2
36
Apr 2024
14
1
4
19
May 2024
13
2
15
Jun 2024
6
2
2
10
Jul 2024
10
2
4
16
Aug 2024
20
0
20
Sep 2024
10
2
0
12
Oct 2024
11
1
0
12
Nov 2024
17
0
17
Dec 2024
10
1
3
14
Jan 2025
14
1
2
17
Feb 2025
17
1
18
Mar 2025
10
3
1
14
Apr 2025
2
3
1
6
May 2025
13
2
2
17
Jun 2025
22
1
1
24
Jul 2025
13
2
1
16
Aug 2025
57
3
3
63
Sep 2025
291
3
1
295
Oct 2025
15
4
0
19
Nov 2025
23
5
5
33
Dec 2025
15
3
1
19
Jan 2026
27
7
5
39
Feb 2026
30
6
3
39
Mar 2026
40
2
2
44
Apr 2026
49
8
4
61
May 2026
23
2
1
26
Jun 2026
6
3
2
11
Jul 2026
3
3
0
6
Aug 2026
5
1
6
Sep 2026
35
13
18
66
Oct 2026
3
1
0
4
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
6
14
6
Mar 2013
11
28
11
Apr 2013
15
35
11
May 2013
43
45
11
Jun 2013
49
55
12
Jul 2013
53
62
12
Aug 2013
57
71
12
Sep 2013
57
77
12
Oct 2013
61
87
12
Nov 2013
64
95
13
Dec 2013
67
100
15
Jan 2014
72
119
17
Feb 2014
78
131
20
Mar 2014
88
138
22
Apr 2014
96
150
24
May 2014
99
160
24
Jun 2014
102
172
24
Jul 2014
106
182
24
Aug 2014
108
191
24
Sep 2014
110
199
25
Oct 2014
110
207
26
Nov 2014
113
216
26
Dec 2014
113
225
26
Jan 2015
123
234
26
Feb 2015
131
234
26
Mar 2015
138
238
27
Apr 2015
150
240
27
May 2015
153
242
27
Jun 2015
158
242
27
Jul 2015
165
243
27
Aug 2015
169
247
27
Sep 2015
172
250
27
Oct 2015
178
253
27
Nov 2015
183
256
27
Dec 2015
183
257
27
Jan 2016
191
258
27
Feb 2016
200
261
27
Mar 2016
210
262
28
Apr 2016
218
263
28
May 2016
228
266
33
Jun 2016
237
271
37
Jul 2016
245
274
40
Aug 2016
253
280
41
Sep 2016
258
280
41
Oct 2016
270
281
45
Nov 2016
272
282
45
Dec 2016
278
283
46
Jan 2017
287
287
47
Feb 2017
294
288
50
Mar 2017
316
292
53
Apr 2017
343
298
57
May 2017
364
300
59
Jun 2017
379
304
61
Jul 2017
382
304
61
Aug 2017
389
311
63
Sep 2017
391
312
63
Oct 2017
394
313
63
Nov 2017
397
314
63
Dec 2017
403
319
63
Jan 2018
410
322
63
Feb 2018
424
323
66
Mar 2018
427
325
66
Apr 2018
437
328
67
May 2018
442
332
68
Jun 2018
444
333
68
Jul 2018
450
335
68
Aug 2018
459
340
68
Sep 2018
466
345
68
Oct 2018
470
347
68
Nov 2018
479
352
68
Dec 2018
485
353
68
Jan 2019
490
356
68
Feb 2019
494
357
68
Mar 2019
494
359
68
Apr 2019
499
366
69
May 2019
501
369
69
Jun 2019
505
370
69
Jul 2019
510
373
70
Aug 2019
515
375
70
Sep 2019
519
377
70
Oct 2019
519
377
70
Nov 2019
525
377
70
Dec 2019
525
377
70
Jan 2020
532
381
70
Feb 2020
536
382
70
Mar 2020
537
384
70
Apr 2020
540
388
71
May 2020
543
389
71
Jun 2020
549
389
71
Jul 2020
559
394
76
Aug 2020
565
397
80
Sep 2020
569
398
80
Oct 2020
575
401
81
Nov 2020
580
402
82
Dec 2020
584
406
83
Jan 2021
589
408
83
Feb 2021
596
413
83
Mar 2021
601
417
83
Apr 2021
606
420
83
May 2021
611
423
83
Jun 2021
618
426
83
Jul 2021
625
428
83
Aug 2021
631
434
84
Sep 2021
634
435
84
Oct 2021
642
437
84
Nov 2021
654
440
84
Dec 2021
661
443
84
Jan 2022
665
445
84
Feb 2022
671
445
84
Mar 2022
677
448
86
Apr 2022
683
454
88
May 2022
687
454
88
Jun 2022
690
454
88
Jul 2022
694
455
88
Aug 2022
701
458
88
Sep 2022
712
460
88
Oct 2022
718
461
89
Nov 2022
730
463
90
Dec 2022
735
464
91
Jan 2023
740
465
91
Feb 2023
748
468
91
Mar 2023
758
469
91
Apr 2023
764
470
91
May 2023
770
474
92
Jun 2023
776
476
94
Jul 2023
787
478
97
Aug 2023
799
481
98
Sep 2023
814
484
102
Oct 2023
823
485
102
Nov 2023
831
485
103
Dec 2023
835
485
103
Jan 2024
842
485
103
Feb 2024
853
485
103
Mar 2024
887
485
105
Apr 2024
901
486
109
May 2024
914
486
111
Jun 2024
920
488
113
Jul 2024
930
490
117
Aug 2024
950
490
117
Sep 2024
960
492
117
Oct 2024
971
493
117
Nov 2024
988
493
117
Dec 2024
998
494
120
Jan 2025
1,012
495
122
Feb 2025
1,029
495
123
Mar 2025
1,039
498
124
Apr 2025
1,041
501
125
May 2025
1,054
503
127
Jun 2025
1,076
504
128
Jul 2025
1,089
506
129
Aug 2025
1,146
509
132
Sep 2025
1,437
512
133
Oct 2025
1,452
516
133
Nov 2025
1,475
521
138
Dec 2025
1,490
524
139
Jan 2026
1,517
531
144
Feb 2026
1,547
537
147
Mar 2026
1,587
539
149
Apr 2026
1,636
547
153
May 2026
1,659
549
154
Jun 2026
1,665
552
156
Jul 2026
1,668
555
156
Aug 2026
1,673
555
157
Sep 2026
1,708
568
175
Oct 2026
1,711
569
175
Cited
Latest update: 02 Oct 2026