Articles | Volume 15, issue 11
https://doi.org/10.5194/amt-15-3329-2022
© Author(s) 2022. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Quantification of lightning-produced NOx over the Pyrenees and the Ebro Valley by using different TROPOMI-NO2 and cloud research products
Download
- Final revised paper (published on 08 Jun 2022)
- Supplement to the final revised paper
- Preprint (discussion started on 08 Nov 2021)
- Supplement to the preprint
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor
| : Report abuse
-
RC1: 'Comment on amt-2021-286', Anonymous Referee #1, 03 Jan 2022
- AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Francisco Javier Perez-Invernon, 04 Feb 2022
-
RC2: 'Comment on amt-2021-286', Anonymous Referee #2, 11 Jan 2022
- AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Francisco Javier Perez-Invernon, 04 Feb 2022
Peer review completion
AR – Author's response | RR – Referee report | ED – Editor decision | EF – Editorial file upload
AR by Francisco Javier Perez-Invernon on behalf of the Authors (04 Feb 2022)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Referee Nomination & Report Request started (09 Mar 2022) by Steffen Beirle
RR by Anonymous Referee #2 (03 May 2022)
ED: Publish subject to minor revisions (review by editor) (09 May 2022) by Steffen Beirle
AR by Francisco Javier Perez-Invernon on behalf of the Authors (10 May 2022)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Publish subject to technical corrections (19 May 2022) by Steffen Beirle
AR by Francisco Javier Perez-Invernon on behalf of the Authors (19 May 2022)
Author's response
Manuscript
Review of ‘Quantification of lightning-produced NOx over the Pyrenees and the Ebro Valley by using different TROPOMI-NO2 and cloud research products’ by Perez-Invernion et al.
This paper attempts to estimate the lightning production efficiency of NOx over the Pyrenees and northeastern Spain in Spring 2018 from 3 sources of information: lightning flash counts, TROPOMI satellite above-cloud NO2 column observations, and modelled NOx:NO2 ratios in the upper troposphere. Each of these have considerable uncertainties associated with them. The strength of the work is that the authors address these uncertainties carefully in their approach. Strong about this paper is the use of two different lightning flash networks, two standalone TROPOMI NO2 products, and different approaches to correct for the tropospheric background NO2 not caused by lightning. This is interesting in its own right, as there are considerable uncertainties associated with counting lightning flashes, with the satellite retrieval process, and with our knowledge about tropospheric background NO2. It is also interesting because applying this mini-ensemble provides a robustness check on the quantitative LNOx production, which is at the lower end of previously reported estimates.
The paper has some serious shortcomings which need to be addressed before publication in AMT can be considered in my opinion:
Specific comments
Figure 1 is not particularly helpful. One way to provide more useful context is to overplot the mean NO2 columns on the map. That way the reader can appreciate the difficulty of distinguishing the lightning NO2 signal from the nearby anthropogenic hotspots such as Toulouse, Bordeaux, and Barcelona.
L34: ‘estima’ --> estimate
L84: Williams et al. (2017) describes the TM5-MP version which is actually used in the NO2 retrieval. I believe this is a more appropriate reference than the Myriokefalitakis-reference.
Williams, J. E., Boersma, K. F., Le Sager, P., and Verstraeten, W. W.: The high-resolution version of TM5-MP for optimized satellite retrievals: description and validation, Geosci. Model Dev., 10, 721-750, doi:10.5194/gmd-10-721-2017, 2017.
L85: where can ‘version 2.1_test’ be found? Please provide a reference. Are v2.1_test data also available for April and May 2018?
L108-109: it is unclear here if the authors have imposed temporal coincidence of lightning flashes with the observation of TROPOMI cloud fractions > 0.95 and OCP < threshold. Or has a time window been taken, such as lightning flashes within a few hours of TROPOMI overpass and TROPOMI fulfilling the above cloud criteria? Please clarify.
P6, Figure 3: I think the authors should show here the detection efficiency for April-May 2018 rather than March 2018 – December 2018. After all, the paper is about the lightning NO2 production in April-May 2018.
L177: it is unclear how the authors have formulated the SCD here. Which slant column do they mean? The total slant column, which also contains contributions from the stratosphere, or the tropospheric slant column?
L180: what is meant with the “absorption of the atmosphere”? I guess this is about the ratio of the slant to vertical (NO2) optical thickness, but it should be clarified.
P9, Figure 4: what was the pressure of the OCP on this day? Please indicate this in the caption. Also indicate the corresponding AMF LNO2 values.
P10, Eq. (1): I suggest to include the TROPOMI measurand, i.e. the NO2 column, here. This is now missing from the equation, which may give the impression that TROPOMI somehow provides a tropospheric NOx column, which is not the case.
L274: the authors state that the free tropospheric NO2 “may be overestimated” in TM5-MP, but I see no supporting evidence for this. Do the authors have any reason to suspect this, or could the TM5-MP NO2 background also be underestimated?
L323 and Tables 1 and 2: the “lower values” of VtropNOx for the DLR vs. KNMI product are unclear to me. Has the Vtropbck been subtracted to arrive at VtropNOx?
L359: “background NOx …activity” is printed in italics. Not clear why. Same on line 371 and 393-394.
P18, Table 3: perhaps useful to also include the overall uncertainty estimate in the table.